Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Smell.dating (smell.dating)
73 points by dluan on March 25, 2016 | hide | past | favorite | 48 comments


For context, studies show that mate compatibility can be determined by the reaction to pheromones. This site is attempting to bring this kind of research to the public in a usable way. This is not some kind of fetish thing for people who like the smell of armpits.


appreciate your effort to make this seem slightly less creepy!


While it certainly sounds odd, my wife has said that when I'm away on business trips she'll take one of my worn shirts and put it on her pillow at night since it smells like me.


I thought this was a pretty common thing.

It's a bit of of a movie/TV trope, especially after a character dies--the widow would try to preserve the scent of their spouse/lover via clothing, pillow, etc.


That's the sweetest damn thing I've ever heard.


Thanks to lapitopi for the contextual link [1]; tldr: attraction can be predicted by perceived smell of sweat, which correlates with genetic compatibility in terms of resistance to disease.

Could use some better marketing to mitigate the ick factor.

Also, a .dating TLD? We need serious reform of the system.

[1] http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/evolution/library/01/6/l_016_08.html


>Also, a .dating TLD? We need serious reform of the system.

Why? So they could fork out $50k to the squatter at smell.com?


"It's like Tinder, but for panty sniffers"


A potential hit in Japan? Context: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jkMGhKGp--Y


you should get on http://fundergame.com/ and pitch the hell out of it!


Interesting concept. I think a lot of people will have issues getting past how strange it seems at first.

What I am wondering though is, shouldn't they include at least a bit of personality stuff in there? If I were going to pay them to send sample to me, I would want to know all 10 of those samples are from someone I have a decent chance of getting along with. Because attraction is not everything.

I also think most people know what gender(s) they are looking for, and would rather not get get a set of samples that includes others. Like what is the point in sending two heterosexual individuals of the same gender eachother's samples? Or sending a homosexual individual a sample from the opposite gender?

A completely random sample of 10 seems inefficient. There should at least be some sort of simple optimizations involved. Unless I am missing something?


Well yes, I would expect five shirts to be women's, and if I'm lucky, perhaps one shirt belongs to a fellow gay man. Often zero.


For those who think this isn't a parody, among the links in the footer is "the useless press". This project is a sibling of

"the Decapitated Animals Dataset" - An open call for projects utilizing New York City decapitated animals data.

"Call to Wait" - A phone line that puts callers on hold for seven years.

And others. http://uselesspress.org/

It might still be an actual thing.. but it's a parody for sure :)


Hey - I worked on Smell Dating (and co-founded Useless Press). Just to be clear, Smell Dating is a real thing - 100 people did in fact sign up, and we've sent them t-shirt samples etc.


Love the idea, but can't this be gamed by using synthetic pheromones? Pheromone colognes for the purpose of attracting women have been available for awhile now.


I too grew up with a subscription to Popular Science. I was under the impression that those were a scam though.


I'm sure a few products out there are scams, but speaking from my own experience/anecdotes I think the real ones do actually work. Specifically the products containing androstenone, androsterone, and the other related endogenous steroid hormones.

I used some (from Amazon, forget the brand) on my neck and my wife literally would not stop hugging me and telling me how great I smelled. She's actually initiated sex a few times after I've applied it.


I'm not to proud to admit that this could solve a significant pain point for me and my wife. If you would be kind enough to look through your amazon history and post a link, I would be tremendously grateful.


Yes but it would be like wearing a deer suit to attract a deer when you're a human. You want someone who matches you and is naturally attracted to you, not someone who doesn't like your smell.


Can't tell if this is legit or a parody of niche dating sites.


Niches dating sites are mostly parodies or clichés. :)


Three days sounds a bit extreme to me. I think a more realistic scenario would be a normal unwashed tshirt as usually most people don't go so long with washing, etc. Maybe though it's so we can more easily determine things. But smell is definitely important. I couldn't date some guys who were very smart and had other things going for them because they smelled bad according to my nose.


Have to admit this is pretty weird, but also genius. This certainly falls under some people's personal preferences.


I can't tell if this is getting upvotes because people think it's a witty parody of dating apps/sites, or because they think it's cool. If it's the latter, I'm somewhat disturbed by that.

Based on the super-creepy background video, I sure hope that the creators of this thing meant for it to be a parody.


It's very clearly not a parody.


Seems like something that people might actually pay for. The smelly shirts alone, that is. There would definitely be people who couldn't care less about actually matching and just want the smells.


Gross, funny, experimental and scientifically plausible. LOVE IT.


How are the 10 samples they send out selected?


We select them randomly...


I'm interested to see how this works out in practice. I would be concerned that some people have enough constraints it is likely that none of ten random other people would be an acceptable match.


So each 1 person who sends in 1 sample receives 10 samples in return. Its a ponzi scheme folks!


They only send a small part of the shirt, so 'one sample' is actually dozens.


Smelly shirt returns, paid for by the sweat of new members.


Is it already April 1st?


This sounds disgusting


You're way too divorced from how disgusting everyday human life is.


Sure, but we don't put "May contain rodent feces and crushed insects" on our ingredients labels, and I'd frankly rather it stay that way.


Relax. It's only smellz.


this assertion isn't hereby a symptom of synesthesia?


I can't imagine anyone using this for real. The concepts funny though.


what the actual fuck


I think it lacks a bit of context. See here: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/evolution/library/01/6/l_016_08.html


A little more context:

http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/sep/08/can-you-...

There was also a study that showed birth control to negatively affect a woman's ability to detect a genetic match by smell:

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/birth-control-pill...


I don't think it's lacking any context. Doesn't make the idea any less strange. : P


Didn't these guys just raise $5 mil (@ $100 mil valuation now)?


What a time to be alive.


2 grody 4 me


Do they allow underware sniff test?




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: