Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The bill as written[0] is limited to social media sites and has an exception for music playlists, so both your examples would be allowed.

[0]https://www.hawley.senate.gov/sites/default/files/2019-07/So...



For YouTube I don't use a playlist, I just let it pick the next recommendation, so that would still be banned.

They added an exception for advertisements, which is too bad since that is the only kind of autoplay video I would really be excited about getting rid of. The definition of autoplay in the bill is "The use of a process that automatically plays music or videos (other than advertisements) without an express, separate prompt by the user." If you are going to get rid of autoplay videos, don't have exceptions for advertisers, that just gives them more power.


Autoplaying advertisements are one of the main reason autoplay is so annoying. WhyTF would they make an exception for this? This seems like obvious corruption.


Yeah, but they kind of have to autoplay ads. Would you find it less annoying to (1) manually click to start playing an ad, and then (2) manually click after the ad is done to play the video? I hope it would be violation of the regulation to play ads ad infinitum after playing a video.


Yes, I'd find it much less annoying to have to manually click to play an ad, because then I can just not click at all, and read the article without having to listen to some stupid video.


Ah I see. This bill seems to only deal with social media / entertainment though (Facebook, YouTube), (unfortunately) not with those super-annoying autoplaying videos on news websites.


Yeah, those are the things I really hate. An ad on YouTube I'm not worried about, because I'm already there to view a video, and at least they have a "click to skip" button that shows up after a certain amount of time.


Its possible to me the auto-play setting something that is enabled voluntarily by the user. This would solve your problem.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: