Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> How is this even legal?

Because "opus-4.6-YYYYMMDD" is a marketing product name for a given price level. You consented to this in the terms and conditions. Nothing in the contract you signed promises anything about weights, quantization, capability, or performance.

Wait until you hear about my ISPs that throttle my "unlimited" "gigabit" connection whenever they want, or my mobile provider that auto-compresses HD video on all platforms, or my local restaurant that just shrinkflationed how much food you get for the same price, or my gym where 'small group' personal trainer sessions went from 5 to 25 people per session, or this fruit basket company that went from 25% honeydew to 75% honeydew, or the literal origin of "your mileage may vary".

Vote with your wallet.

 help



> Nothing in the contract promises capability or performance.

Taken to its conclusion, Anthropic could silently replace Opus with Haiku quality internals and you'd have no recourse. If that sounds absurd, that's exactly where the legal argument lives. Mandatory consumer protection provisions like on misleading omissions cannot be waived by clicking "I agree." Withholding material information about a product you're paying a premium for isn't covered by T&Cs. It's the specific thing those laws were written to address.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: