Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Dang that hurt to read, here's an advertisement!"

Why is this every 3rd comment on this site? Every single post has multiple comments that are

"I hate that, here's my solution"

 help



This is the second comment like that. It was honestly not intended - it was actually me trying to respond in my own context to the post, and WHY I was responding; "why" is more important to me than "what," and I have a hard time saying "this" without explaining why I felt "this" - or at least trying to explore it. I'm working on a site; reading the "this kind of thing is how people do things these days" actually made the concept of working on the site (which I hope has value) harder. That's what I was saying, or trying to; the "advertisement" was context, not intent, or else I'd have tried to post my own thing to HN saying "look at how ossum my seite are!"

Market-by-contradiction is huge these days. Almost as big as We're-Evil-So-What marketing!

> "I hate that, here's my solution"

HN comments have always been like that, or rather "here's my approach to circumvent that annoyance".

What's your alternative? I prefer that style over comments that stop already at "I hate that", as curiosity should be more than an expression of a dismissive opinion.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: